Reddit is moving toward mandatory logins
After 20 years of open browsing, Reddit will test a logged-in-only experience. Google’s AI answers send it fewer visitors, and logged-in users are where its money is.
Reddit will test a logged-in-only experience in select markets outside the US this quarter, before a wider rollout. The reason is traffic: referrals from Google fell “meaningfully” as AI Overviews and AI Mode answer questions without sending anyone on. CEO Steve Huffman put it bluntly: “The AI Mode does not drive traffic, not for us and not to anybody as far as I know.” The stock fell 29% on October 30, its worst day since going public.
Why it matters for communities
For two decades, the answer to almost any question was a Reddit thread you could open without an account. That open layer is what made community knowledge findable. Now the biggest community platform on the web is closing it, not because its communities asked for it, but because the traffic deal between platforms and search engines broke.
The people who wrote those answers don’t get a say. Their knowledge was the product in every deal: first for search traffic, then for AI training, now as a reason to sign in. When a platform’s business changes, the community’s work changes hands with it.
Technology Org
Reddit Tests Logged-In Experience as Traffic Drops
Reddit will test a logged-in experience in select markets after Google’s AI features cut search traffic and its shares fell.
Read the source →
More on Platform Shifts
- Reddit is turning community conversations into AI-powered product reviews. Who controls the value?Reddit Reviews uses AI to sum up what its communities say about some 10,000 products. Each comment still links back to the discussion it came from. Platform Shift
- Discourse says a solved problem matters more than a clickReddit’s login wall follows its ad model, Discourse argues. For a support forum, an AI answer that fixes the problem is a win, as long as the source keeps its credit. Platform Shift
- Microsoft moves Viva Engage communities into TeamsCompany communities now sit next to chats and channels in Teams, with an agent that drafts answers to open questions. In public preview, rolling out in phases. Platform Shift